Skip to content

TRK (Star Trek): simulated card strength

A cold-start card list for TRK, made from simulated games alone, before any human play data existed for the set. It is a prior, not a measurement of how the cards play for people. Every card is in TRK.csv (list id trk-nonet-11k).

  • 11,000 games, 10,970 decided, 0 errors
  • 291 cards ranked of 292 eligible
  • 0.758 split-half reliability (Spearman, ridge value)
  • 0.403 the recipe's agreement with 17Lands on FDN, at 3,000 games

How the list was made

  • Tool: a valuation tool that is not in this repository, from a local build with uncommitted changes; the gorge commit was not recorded.
  • Setup: az search at 25 simulations, 11,000 games, seed 21.
  • Decks: random two-colour decks of 23 distinct nonland cards (15 creatures) drawn uniformly from each colour pair's eligible cards, plus basics. 292 TRK cards were eligible.
  • Pilot: the az search with no network, 25 simulations per searched decision, on both seats. It knows no card, so the list carries no knowledge from another set.
  • Games: 11,000 played, 0 errors. 10,970 were decided; 22 ended without a winner and 8 stalled, and those 30 are left out of the estimate.
  • Estimator: in-hand membership. Each seat's in-hand set is its opening hand after mulligans plus every card it later drew (the set 17Lands counts for GIH WR). A ridge linear-probability model (lambda 50) of the seat's win on in-hand membership, fitted over the 21,940 decided seat-games; the value is the coefficient plus 0.5. The shrunk in-hand win rate, (wins + 10) / (n + 20), is also stored, as gih in the CSV.
  • Published prior: the ridge ranks are mapped onto the distribution of FDN's 17Lands gih_wr (cards with at least 2,000 games) by quantile matching, giving the "Prior (gih_wr scale)" column below. The ranks are the ridge ranks: Spearman between the prior and the ridge value is 0.999998 (rounded to 6 decimals; the stored prior is rounded to 4 decimals, which makes ties). This prior is TRK's draft-bot rating file, draft/limited/pickbot/ratings/TRK.json (generated from this CSV by draft/limited/pickbot/internal/gentrk).
  • Date: 2026-11-03.

A second 11,000-game batch (seed 22) was planned to follow. No output or log of it exists, so this list is the first batch alone.

Validity

There is no 17Lands data for TRK, so the list cannot be scored directly. What can be said:

  • Split-half reliability. Games 1 to 5,500 and 5,501 to 10,990 were fitted separately (the last 10 are in neither). Spearman between the halves over 291 cards is 0.758 for the ridge value and 0.745 for the shrunk in-hand rate. Adjacent ranks are not reliable; the intervals in the table show how far apart two cards must be.
  • The same binary and recipe on FDN, where 17Lands data exists (3,000 games, seed 11): Spearman against 17Lands GIH WR over 262 cards is 0.403 for the ridge value and 0.378 for the in-hand rate; its split-half is 0.360. That run has about a quarter of this one's games and is noisy, so it probably understates what the recipe reaches at this size; it does not measure it. See FDN, list fdn-nonet-3k.
  • An earlier 20,000-game no-network FDN run scored 0.50 by in-hand win rate, the same ceiling as the scripted bot. Its data no longer exists, so that figure cannot be re-checked here.

Figures are rounded to 3 decimals.

Known biases

The same recipe on FDN, compared card by card with 17Lands (mean of simulated percentile minus 17Lands percentile, 0 to 100 scale, 262 cards; FDN has the method):

Group Cards Mean percentile difference
Text mentions sacrifice 25 -15.7
Mana value 1-2 90 -5.8
Mana value 6+ 30 +0.0
Enchantments (Enchantment in the type line) 18 +10.3
Instants 36 -14.7
Artifacts (not creature or enchantment) 12 -17.6

On this list, 16 of the 291 measured cards are colourless; none is in the top 40, 6 are in the bottom 20, and their median rank is 246.5. Colourless cards are eligible for every deck, so they have 1,394 to 2,102 games in hand (median 1,456.5) where coloured cards have a median of 778. Read together with the artifact figure above, the bottom of the list probably overstates how weak the colourless artifacts are.

Group means are from the fdn-nonet-3k list in FDN.csv, rounded to 1 decimal; the colourless counts from the colour, rank and games_in_hand columns of TRK.csv.

The list

Value is the ridge value at 4 decimals; the interval is value ± 1.96 standard errors from the ridge fit. Games in hand is the number of decided seat-games in which the card was in hand. Prior is the stored published prior. Rarity is from gorge's draft/limited/setdata/sets/TRK.json at gorge b14b8a543; colour is from the card's colour bits (W, U, B, R, G; C for colourless). Every eligible card has a rarity there.

One eligible card, All Good Things..., was never in a hand in any decided game; it has no value and no rank, and the published prior gives it 0.5499 only because the ridge leaves it at 0.5.

Top 40 of 291:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand Prior (gih_wr scale)
1 Sheoldred, the Apocalypse M B 0.6995 0.6681 to 0.7310 849 0.6412
2 Georgiou, Terran Emperor M B 0.6586 0.6260 to 0.6912 804 0.6289
3 Captain Jean-Luc Picard M W 0.6502 0.6185 to 0.6819 833 0.6265
4 Excalbian Gamemaster M W 0.6442 0.6127 to 0.6757 848 0.6226
5 Mugato U G 0.6150 0.5818 to 0.6481 751 0.621
6 Jadzia Dax, Living Legacy M G 0.6137 0.5820 to 0.6455 834 0.6206
7 Khan, Despot by Design U R 0.6053 0.5735 to 0.6370 835 0.6202
8 Interstellar Effigy C U 0.5915 0.5600 to 0.6230 857 0.6193
9 V'Ger, the Intruder U U 0.5901 0.5591 to 0.6212 889 0.6183
10 Spock, Always Your Friend U UR 0.5890 0.5378 to 0.6403 237 0.6181
11 The Caretaker R U 0.5888 0.5578 to 0.6197 900 0.6171
12 Vulcan Mind-Meld U U 0.5876 0.5515 to 0.6237 608 0.6161
13 Captain James T. Kirk M R 0.5807 0.5498 to 0.6116 891 0.6154
14 Holo-Engineer R G 0.5778 0.5452 to 0.6104 778 0.6141
15 Bristly Bill, Spine Sower M G 0.5763 0.5446 to 0.6080 834 0.6122
16 Gwyndala, the Progeny R U 0.5753 0.5451 to 0.6055 941 0.6099
17 The Wrath of Khan R R 0.5742 0.5364 to 0.6121 540 0.6064
18 Captain Kathryn Janeway M G 0.5724 0.5398 to 0.6051 786 0.6045
19 Shuttle Ace C W 0.5723 0.5408 to 0.6038 854 0.6043
20 Munitions Enthusiast U R 0.5717 0.5408 to 0.6027 884 0.6041
21 Deanna Troi, Psychic Counsel R W 0.5715 0.5398 to 0.6033 836 0.6035
22 Captain Jonathan Archer R G 0.5702 0.5378 to 0.6026 792 0.6012
23 Captain Michael Burnham U R 0.5673 0.5356 to 0.5990 836 0.5954
24 Gul Dukat, Colonial Prefect M B 0.5661 0.5337 to 0.5985 790 0.5935
25 Silicate Surveyor C R 0.5655 0.5338 to 0.5972 837 0.5911
26 Syndicate Liquidators U G 0.5653 0.5328 to 0.5977 783 0.5911
27 Primary Unimatrix Adjunct R W 0.5647 0.5335 to 0.5960 866 0.591
28 Targ Wrangler U R 0.5576 0.5265 to 0.5887 874 0.5909
29 Will Riker, First in the Field R R 0.5563 0.5242 to 0.5884 813 0.5904
30 Saurian Explorer C G 0.5563 0.5246 to 0.5879 836 0.59
31 Cha'DIch Investigator C B 0.5561 0.5238 to 0.5884 802 0.5892
32 The Measure of a Man U W 0.5552 0.5184 to 0.5921 580 0.5879
33 Photosynthetic Physician C G 0.5523 0.5204 to 0.5842 824 0.5868
34 Ghost of Illyria U W 0.5514 0.5193 to 0.5835 813 0.5862
35 Una Chin-Riley, Number One U W 0.5511 0.5189 to 0.5833 805 0.5861
36 Fugitive Listener C B 0.5511 0.5187 to 0.5834 800 0.5857
37 Dominion Assault Force C G 0.5509 0.5176 to 0.5843 741 0.5854
38 Khan, Vengeful Heart M B 0.5509 0.5190 to 0.5828 828 0.5848
39 Antagonist Incorporator R W 0.5507 0.5198 to 0.5817 896 0.5847
40 Dahar Master C R 0.5505 0.5187 to 0.5824 829 0.584

Bottom 20:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand Prior (gih_wr scale)
272 Saavik, Stoic Student U W 0.4306 0.3996 to 0.4617 886 0.4872
273 Stable Wormhole R G 0.4288 0.3921 to 0.4656 580 0.487
274 A Good Day to Die C B 0.4288 0.3925 to 0.4651 599 0.4867
275 Romulan Bird-of-Prey R U 0.4264 0.3905 to 0.4622 620 0.4864
276 Kirk, Commanding Officer U WR 0.4258 0.3721 to 0.4796 199 0.486
277 Flare of Fortitude M W 0.4257 0.3877 to 0.4637 533 0.4851
278 Savvy Profiteer C R 0.4256 0.3946 to 0.4565 889 0.4841
279 Peace in Our Time R W 0.4254 0.3880 to 0.4629 561 0.483
280 U.S.S. Enterprise-D, Galaxy-Class R C 0.4253 0.4010 to 0.4497 1478 0.4819
281 Perils of the Past C R 0.4238 0.3851 to 0.4624 507 0.481
282 Ensign Pavel Chekov U U 0.4222 0.3903 to 0.4541 828 0.4784
283 Final Frontier C G 0.4188 0.3832 to 0.4544 626 0.4759
284 The Holodeck R C 0.4185 0.3937 to 0.4433 1418 0.4709
285 D'Vana Tendi, Optimistic Ensign U UG 0.4160 0.3629 to 0.4691 209 0.4681
286 Engineered Explosives R C 0.4140 0.3896 to 0.4385 1460 0.4677
287 Combadge U C 0.4071 0.3824 to 0.4318 1426 0.4648
288 Anthropological Mission U U 0.4049 0.3679 to 0.4418 576 0.457
289 Isolinear Processor U C 0.4009 0.3764 to 0.4254 1492 0.4479
290 Kobayashi Maru Scenario M U 0.3752 0.3388 to 0.4116 598 0.4463
291 Replicator R C 0.3619 0.3373 to 0.3864 1453 0.4384