Skip to content

Card strength lists

Per-set card values estimated from simulated games alone. Each page says how its list was made, how far it can be trusted, and its known biases; the CSV beside it holds every card.

Set List id Pilot Estimator Games played Spearman vs 17Lands GIH WR Date Built from
TRK trk-nonet-11k az search, no network, 25 sims ridge on in-hand membership 11,000 none (no 17Lands data) 2026-11-03 a local build with uncommitted changes
FDN fdn-bot-80k scripted bot shrunk in-hand win rate 80,000 0.518 2026-10-16 gorge 10f10c858 (inferred)
FDN fdn-azc6g3-20k az search, az-c6 g3 network, 25 sims shrunk in-hand win rate 20,000 0.609 2026-10-16 gorge 10f10c858 (inferred)
FDN fdn-nonet-3k az search, no network, 25 sims ridge on in-hand membership 3,000 0.403 2026-11-03 the same build as TRK

Agreement with human play, Spearman ρ against 17Lands GIH WR on FDN:

  • simulated list
  • rarity alone (C < U < R < M)
  • bar length is ρ on a 0–1 scale

Spearman figures are over the 262 FDN cards with at least 500 17Lands games-in-hand, rounded to 3 decimals; rarity alone scores 0.217. The fdn-azc6g3-20k network was trained on FDN, so that list is not a cold-start result. fdn-nonet-3k is the FDN calibration of the TRK recipe.

How the lists were made

A valuation tool built on the draftlab composition API (not in this repository) builds random two-colour decks, plays them with one pilot on both seats, and writes one line per game with each seat's in-hand cards. The values for every card are then fitted at once, and the CSVs and every derived figure on these pages (the Spearman figures, the split-half reliabilities, the 95% intervals and the bias tables) come from the game files. Each page states its method in words.

Runs described in the experiment's write-up whose data no longer exists (the 2026-10-14 FDN runs) have no list here; the FDN page quotes their figures and Cold-start card valuation has the full results.

17Lands data

FDN.csv and the FDN page carry 17Lands GIH WR beside the simulated values, from gorge's draft/limited/pickbot/ratings/FDN.json: data from 17Lands (https://www.17lands.com), public datasets, CC BY 4.0.