Bot comparison¶
Every bot gorged serves, side by side. The registry is bots/registry.go, as cmd/gorged links it: the seven built-ins of
bots/all, the experimental search, SpellBench and cast-profile policies, and the three network policies, which register only when
a server names their network. A test keeps this table in step with it (cmd/gorged/docs_table_test.go). Costs are measured on gorge, 2026-10-31, from Bot speed. The code behind each verdict is on
Each bot in detail.
| Bot | What it does | Engines | Seats | Cost per decision | Fair or clairvoyant |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
bot |
The default. Hand-written rules, a two-ply combat simulation on auto-pay tables, Forge's mulligan rule | gorge, dirac | any, human or bot | 29.7 µs | fair: sees only its redacted view |
forge-heuristic |
bot plus rules re-expressed from Forge's AI: targeting, removal timing, attachments, gang blocks |
gorge, dirac | any, human or bot | not measured | fair |
forge-heuristic-hold |
forge-heuristic with hold-instant on: keeps instants back outside response windows |
gorge, dirac | any, human or bot | not measured | fair |
lethal-pressure |
The older heuristic: an attack-into-lethal rule, no combat simulation, a coin-flip mulligan | gorge, dirac | any, human or bot | not measured | fair |
sb-tactical |
SpellBench's scored tactical heuristic, pricing plays through a redealt root | gorge, dirac | bot-only, 2 seats | not measured | fair on hidden cards, but reads every seat's decklist |
az-redeal |
AlphaZero-style tree search, 100 simulations per decision, no network | gorge only | bot-only, 2 seats | about 106 ms per searched decision | fair on hidden cards (determinised redeal), but reads every seat's decklist |
az-redeal-maxn |
az-redeal with the opponents' decision points in its tree, each opponent maximising its own value there (max^n), not all of them ganging up |
gorge only | bot-only, up to 4 seats | about 106 ms per searched decision (2-seat; 4-seat pod cost unmeasured) | fair on hidden cards (determinised redeal), but reads every seat's decklist |
cast-profile |
bot playing from a cast profile; the embedded default is intent-identical to bot |
gorge | any, human or bot | as bot (declared) |
fair: sees only its redacted view |
sb-first |
SpellBench's first-option builtin | gorge | bot-only, 2 seats | negligible (declared) | fair on hidden cards, but reads every seat's decklist |
sb-uniform |
SpellBench's uniform-random builtin | gorge | bot-only, 2 seats | negligible (declared) | fair on hidden cards, but reads every seat's decklist |
sb-heuristic |
SpellBench's heuristic builtin | gorge | bot-only, 2 seats | negligible (declared) | fair on hidden cards, but reads every seat's decklist |
sb-search-lite-atk |
sb-tactical plus a determinised search of its top plays and its attack over four redealt worlds, two turns deep |
gorge only | bot-only, 2 seats | 219 ms mean per searched decision (declared) | fair on hidden cards (determinised redeal), but reads every seat's decklist |
search |
The search teacher: replans the covered decisions over sampled worlds, bot elsewhere |
gorge only | bot-only, 2 seats | 664 ms mean per searched decision (declared) | fair on hidden cards (determinised redeal), but reads every seat's decklist |
Fair means the bot uses only what its seat can see. Clairvoyant means it reads the opponent's hand, the library order or a clone of the real engine. No registered bot is clairvoyant. The search bots redeal the hidden cards from their own observations; they deal from each seat's real decklist, so a server never seats them against a person. Clairvoyant search exists only as a bench ceiling.
The four heuristic bots answer on every wire: in process, over HTTP, and as a SpellBench v2 agent
(spellbench-gorge-agent -policy <name>). The search bots need an engine root, which gorged and testkit/bench supply and
mtgsim and the v2 agent (server/spellbench/agent/policies.go:44) do not. dirac serves the first five; it deals no search roots.
The rows from cast-profile down are linked by cmd/gorged beside bots/all, so only gorged and binaries that link the same
packages offer them.
Formats and server offer¶
| Name | Formats, seats | Offered by gorged |
Package |
|---|---|---|---|
bot |
constructed and Commander, any | yes | bots/bot |
forge-heuristic |
constructed and Commander, any | yes | bots/forgeheuristic |
forge-heuristic-hold |
constructed and Commander, any | yes | bots/forgeheuristic |
lethal-pressure |
constructed and Commander, any | yes; gorged's default -bot-policy |
bots/lethalpressure |
sb-tactical |
constructed, 2 | no: reads every seat's decklist | bots/sbtactical |
az-redeal |
constructed, 2 | no: reads every seat's decklist | bots/azredeal |
az-redeal-maxn |
constructed and Commander, up to 4 | no: reads every seat's decklist | bots/azredeal |
cast-profile |
constructed and Commander, any | yes | bots/castprofile |
sb-first, sb-uniform, sb-heuristic |
constructed, 2 | no: reads every seat's decklist | bots/sbbuiltin |
sb-search-lite-atk |
constructed, 2 | no: reads every seat's decklist | bots/sbsearch |
search |
constructed, 2 | no: reads every seat's decklist | bots/search |