Skip to content

FDN (Foundations): simulated card strength

Three card lists for FDN, each made from simulated games alone. FDN is the calibration set: 17Lands publishes human games-in-hand win rates (GIH WR) for it, so every list here can be scored against human play. The 17Lands figures are used only to score the lists, never to make them. Every card of every list is in FDN.csv (column list).

List id Pilot Games played (decided) Estimator ranked by Spearman vs 17Lands GIH WR Date Built from
fdn-bot-80k scripted bot 80,000 (79,994) shrunk in-hand win rate 0.518 2026-10-16 gorge 10f10c858 (inferred)
fdn-azc6g3-20k az search with the az-c6 generation 3 network 20,000 (19,993) shrunk in-hand win rate 0.609 2026-10-16 gorge 10f10c858 (inferred)
fdn-nonet-3k az search, no network 3,000 (3,000) ridge on in-hand membership 0.403 2026-11-03 a local build with uncommitted changes

Rarity alone (C < U < R < M) scores 0.217 on the same 262 cards. Spearman is rounded to 3 decimals.

How the lists were made

All three come from one valuation tool, which is not in this repository. It builds random two-colour decks of 23 distinct nonland cards (15 creatures) drawn uniformly from each colour pair's eligible cards, plus basics, plays them with one pilot on both seats, and writes one line per game with each seat's in-hand cards (opening hand after mulligans plus every card drawn later, the set 17Lands counts for GIH WR). 265 FDN cards were eligible. An offline script then fits every card at once:

  • gih: the shrunk in-hand win rate, (wins + 10) / (n + 20), where n is the number of decided seat-games with the card in hand.
  • ridge: a ridge linear-probability model (lambda 50) of the seat's win on in-hand membership, coefficient plus 0.5.

Games without a winner and stalled games are left out. Both estimates for every list are in FDN.csv; the "Value" column there is the one each list is ranked by.

Scripted bot pilot.

  • Setup: random mode, 80,000 games, seed 7. The pilot is gorge's scripted bot policy (recorded as bot@1).
  • Games: 80,000 played, 0 errors; 159,988 decided seat-games, so 79,994 decided games.
  • Ranked by gih. This gih column was the teacher for the stage-0 drafter (draft RL).
  • Date: 2026-10-16.
  • Commit: no build stamp survives; the run is attributed to gorge 10f10c858, and the tool was unchanged from gorge main 5799819d6. Uncommitted changes cannot be ruled out.

az search with a trained network.

  • Setup: two chunks of 10,000 games with seeds 11 and 12, az search at 25 simulations with the az-c6 generation 3 network; the two game files were concatenated.
  • Pilot: az search, 25 simulations per searched decision, on both seats, guided by the az-c6 generation 3 network. That network was trained by self-play on 17Lands FDN decks (AZ loop), so it has seen these cards. This list is therefore not a cold-start measurement.
  • Games: 2 × 10,000 played, 0 errors; 39,986 decided seat-games, so 19,993 decided games. In the first chunk, 125 of 17,296,675 simulations found no world and 5 decisions were refused; the second had none.
  • Ranked by gih. It was the teacher for a second stage-0 drafter.
  • Date: 2026-10-16.
  • Commit: as for fdn-bot-80k: gorge 10f10c858.

az search with no network.

  • Setup: az search at 25 simulations, 3,000 games, seed 11, the same setup as the TRK run.
  • Pilot: az search with no network, both seats. It knows no card, which makes this the calibration of the recipe used for TRK.
  • Games: 3,000 played, 0 errors, all decided (6,000 seat-games).
  • Ranked by ridge, as the TRK list is. A refit of the ridge from the game file matches the run's own values to 1.2e-16.
  • Date: 2026-11-03.
  • Commit: a local build with uncommitted changes; the gorge commit was not recorded.

Validity

Spearman rank correlation with 17Lands GIH WR (from the public Premier Draft dataset, 791,159 games) over the 262 cards that have at least 500 17Lands games-in-hand and were in a simulated hand:

List gih ridge Split-half
fdn-bot-80k 0.518 0.483 not available (game file deleted)
fdn-azc6g3-20k 0.609 0.593 not available (game file deleted)
fdn-nonet-3k 0.378 0.403 0.360 (ridge, first vs last 1,500 games)
rarity alone 0.217

Earlier runs, recorded in the experiment's write-up and no longer on disk:

  • Scripted bot pilot, 2026-10-14: agreement with 17Lands stops rising at about 300,000 games, at 0.50; at 188,244 games the in-hand win rate scores 0.49 and the deck regression 0.50; split-half reliability is 0.96 for the regression and 0.97 for the in-hand win rate. A second scripted pilot (lethal-pressure, 500,000 games) scores 0.51. Rarity alone scores 0.22, which these lists reproduce as 0.217.
  • az-c4 network pilot, 25 simulations, 20,000 games: 0.57 by in-hand win rate.
  • No-network az pilot, 20,000 games: 0.50 by in-hand win rate.

A maintainer's note gives the bot split-half as 0.957; the write-up rounds it to 0.96. Neither primary file survives.

The 10-16 bot list (0.518 at 80,000 games) scores a little above the 10-14 bot figures (0.48 to 0.50 between 100,000 and 500,000 games). The two runs used different builds: the search, payment-plan and manual-tap fixes the write-up lists reached gorge main (e10db2ef3, an ancestor of 5799819d6) between them. This page does not test which change moved it.

ρ is computed as the runs' own analysis does: average ranks for ties, Pearson on ranks. The 17Lands figures are gorge's draft/limited/pickbot/ratings/FDN.json (17Lands data, CC BY 4.0, "Data from 17Lands (https://www.17lands.com), public datasets").

Known biases

For each card, the percentile of its simulated value (the list's ranking estimator) minus the percentile of its 17Lands GIH WR, both on a 0 to 100 scale over the 262 scored cards. A negative group mean means the simulation rates the group lower than human play does. Groups come from each card's mana value, type line, and whether its text mentions sacrifice.

Where simulation disagrees with 17Lands (FDN, percentile points) fdn-bot-80k fdn-azc6g3-20k fdn-nonet-3k -25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 +5 +10 +15 Text mentions sacrifice (25) Text mentions sacrifice, fdn-bot-80k: -20.3 Text mentions sacrifice, fdn-azc6g3-20k: -12.2 Text mentions sacrifice, fdn-nonet-3k: -15.7 Mana value 1-2 (90) Mana value 1-2, fdn-bot-80k: -8.9 Mana value 1-2, fdn-azc6g3-20k: -4.8 Mana value 1-2, fdn-nonet-3k: -5.8 Mana value 3 (70) Mana value 3, fdn-bot-80k: +2.3 Mana value 3, fdn-azc6g3-20k: +4.6 Mana value 3, fdn-nonet-3k: +3.1 Mana value 4 (44) Mana value 4, fdn-bot-80k: +4.6 Mana value 4, fdn-azc6g3-20k: +4.3 Mana value 4, fdn-nonet-3k: +6.3 Mana value 5 (28) Mana value 5, fdn-bot-80k: +5.0 Mana value 5, fdn-azc6g3-20k: +1.3 Mana value 5, fdn-nonet-3k: +1.1 Mana value 6+ (30) Mana value 6+, fdn-bot-80k: +10.0 Mana value 6+, fdn-azc6g3-20k: -3.9 Mana value 6+, fdn-nonet-3k: +0.0 Enchantments (18) Enchantments, fdn-bot-80k: +9.1 Enchantments, fdn-azc6g3-20k: +4.7 Enchantments, fdn-nonet-3k: +10.3 Creatures (162) Creatures, fdn-bot-80k: +6.2 Creatures, fdn-azc6g3-20k: +4.0 Creatures, fdn-nonet-3k: +4.5 Instants (36) Instants, fdn-bot-80k: -19.4 Instants, fdn-azc6g3-20k: -13.3 Instants, fdn-nonet-3k: -14.7 Sorceries (29) Sorceries, fdn-bot-80k: -10.3 Sorceries, fdn-azc6g3-20k: -5.6 Sorceries, fdn-nonet-3k: -1.7 Artifacts (12) Artifacts, fdn-bot-80k: -2.7 Artifacts, fdn-azc6g3-20k: -2.7 Artifacts, fdn-nonet-3k: -17.6 simulation rates the group lower ← 0 → higher than human play
Group Cards fdn-bot-80k fdn-azc6g3-20k fdn-nonet-3k
Text mentions sacrifice 25 -20.3 -12.2 -15.7
Mana value 1-2 90 -8.9 -4.8 -5.8
Mana value 3 70 +2.3 +4.6 +3.1
Mana value 4 44 +4.6 +4.3 +6.3
Mana value 5 28 +5.0 +1.3 +1.1
Mana value 6+ 30 +10.0 -3.9 +0.0
Enchantments (Enchantment in the type line) 18 +9.1 +4.7 +10.3
Creatures 162 +6.2 +4.0 +4.5
Instants 36 -19.4 -13.3 -14.7
Sorceries 29 -10.3 -5.6 -1.7
Artifacts (not creature or enchantment) 12 -2.7 -2.7 -17.6

The write-up's residual chart for the 10-14 bot run (500,000 games, simulated minus 17Lands in-hand percentile) gives: sacrifice text (7 cards) -34.0; mana value 2 (60) -12.6; mana value 1 (30) -7.5; instants (36) -5.0; creatures (162) -3.2; mana value 3 (70) +3.8; mana value 4 (44) +5.1; sorceries (29) +8.8; mana value 6+ (30) +11.7; enchantments (18) +22.6. Its sacrifice group is 7 cards, a narrower definition than the 25 cards "mentioning sacrifice" here, and its data is gone, so the two sacrifice figures are not directly comparable.

The biases hold in direction on the 10-16 bot list: sacrifice cards and mana value 1-2 rate low; mana value 6+ and enchantments rate high. Two groups differ: instants rate much lower here (-19.4 against -5.0) and sorceries change sign (-10.3 against +8.8). With a trained network (fdn-azc6g3-20k) the sacrifice, cheap-card, enchantment and instant biases shrink and the 6+ bias changes sign. The write-up names the likely causes: a pilot that misuses sacrifice outlets and holds up instant-speed mana poorly, games that run longer than human games, and random 15-creature decks that misjudge board wipes and synergy cards.

Group means are rounded to 1 decimal.

The lists

Value is the list's ranking estimator at 4 decimals. The interval is value ± 1.96 standard errors: for gih, sqrt(gih (1 - gih) / (n + 20)); for ridge, from the ridge fit. Games in hand is n. Rarity is from gorge's draft/limited/setdata/sets/FDN.json at gorge b14b8a543; colour is from the card's colour bits (W, U, B, R, G; C for colourless). 17Lands GIH WR is the stored value in gorge's pickbot/ratings/FDN.json; where it rests on fewer than 500 games, the count is shown and the card is left out of every Spearman figure above.

fdn-bot-80k

Top 30 of 265:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand 17Lands GIH WR
1 Omniscience M U 0.7242 0.7112 to 0.7371 4537 0.3704 (27 games)
2 Elenda, Saint of Dusk R WB 0.6483 0.6245 to 0.6721 1524 0.6154
3 Sire of Seven Deaths M C 0.6365 0.6290 to 0.6441 15516 0.6203
4 Bloodthirsty Conqueror M B 0.6224 0.6106 to 0.6342 6453 0.6272
5 Spinner of Souls R G 0.6197 0.6074 to 0.6319 5985 0.6211
6 Quilled Greatwurm M G 0.6150 0.6026 to 0.6275 5874 0.55
7 Zimone, Paradox Sculptor M UG 0.6099 0.5860 to 0.6337 1582 0.6263
8 Twinflame Tyrant M R 0.6018 0.5898 to 0.6139 6289 0.6048
9 Empyrean Eagle U WU 0.5911 0.5676 to 0.6146 1665 0.591
10 Vivien Reid M G 0.5897 0.5755 to 0.6038 4608 0.6139
11 Koma, World-Eater R UG 0.5876 0.5636 to 0.6116 1595 0.5693
12 Serra Angel U W 0.5829 0.5706 to 0.5952 6175 0.5477
13 Perforating Artist U BR 0.5818 0.5572 to 0.6064 1527 0.5748
14 Felling Blow U G 0.5812 0.5671 to 0.5953 4660 0.5871
15 Felidar Savior C W 0.5809 0.5688 to 0.5930 6355 0.5736
16 Vampire Nighthawk U B 0.5795 0.5676 to 0.5915 6556 0.5823
17 Ashroot Animist R RG 0.5795 0.5539 to 0.6050 1414 0.5847
18 Herald of Eternal Dawn M W 0.5778 0.5656 to 0.5901 6262 0.5773
19 Treetop Snarespinner C G 0.5778 0.5653 to 0.5904 5942 0.5462
20 Ghalta, Primal Hunger R G 0.5744 0.5618 to 0.5870 5915 0.5523
21 Authority of the Consuls R W 0.5743 0.5603 to 0.5883 4791 0.5203
22 Angel of Finality U W 0.5742 0.5619 to 0.5865 6208 0.5668
23 Exemplar of Light R W 0.5739 0.5617 to 0.5862 6216 0.5899
24 Beast-Kin Ranger C G 0.5739 0.5615 to 0.5863 6103 0.5523
25 Arahbo, the First Fang R W 0.5728 0.5607 to 0.5849 6410 0.6092
26 Dazzling Angel C W 0.5726 0.5605 to 0.5847 6433 0.5778
27 Cackling Prowler C G 0.5721 0.5595 to 0.5847 5906 0.5411
28 Scrawling Crawler R C 0.5686 0.5609 to 0.5763 15931 0.5755
29 Guarded Heir U W 0.5684 0.5561 to 0.5806 6247 0.5676
30 Needletooth Pack U G 0.5674 0.5549 to 0.5799 6032 0.5342

Bottom 15:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand 17Lands GIH WR
251 Goblin Negotiation U R 0.4306 0.4157 to 0.4454 4235 0.5195
252 Hidetsugu's Second Rite U R 0.4276 0.4130 to 0.4422 4400 0.5624
253 Seismic Rupture U R 0.4267 0.4119 to 0.4414 4304 0.5013
254 Fanatical Firebrand C R 0.4214 0.4092 to 0.4336 6262 0.53
255 Time Stop R U 0.4200 0.4055 to 0.4345 4442 0.4751
256 Day of Judgment R W 0.4143 0.4002 to 0.4284 4694 0.5911
257 Fleeting Flight C W 0.4140 0.4001 to 0.4279 4806 0.5644
258 Axgard Cavalry C R 0.4077 0.3956 to 0.4198 6328 0.5214
259 Twinblade Blessing U W 0.4054 0.3915 to 0.4194 4733 0.4683
260 Ravenous Amulet U C 0.4012 0.3922 to 0.4101 11481 0.5171
261 Thousand-Year Storm R UR 0.3996 0.3698 to 0.4294 1016 0.3479
262 Sure Strike C R 0.3992 0.3848 to 0.4137 4411 0.5241
263 Bulk Up U R 0.3935 0.3790 to 0.4081 4300 0.483
264 Blanchwood Armor U G 0.3749 0.3608 to 0.3889 4544 0.5202
265 Hungry Ghoul C B 0.3538 0.3424 to 0.3653 6675 0.5562

fdn-azc6g3-20k

Top 30 of 265:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand 17Lands GIH WR
1 Omniscience M U 0.7952 0.7708 to 0.8196 1030 0.3704 (27 games)
2 Elenda, Saint of Dusk R WB 0.6676 0.6194 to 0.7158 347 0.6154
3 Bloodthirsty Conqueror M B 0.6362 0.6117 to 0.6606 1467 0.6272
4 Twinflame Tyrant M R 0.6347 0.6099 to 0.6596 1420 0.6048
5 Liliana, Dreadhorde General M B 0.6268 0.5985 to 0.6550 1108 0.6412
6 Ashroot Animist R RG 0.6238 0.5707 to 0.6770 299 0.5847
7 Vivien Reid M G 0.6224 0.5931 to 0.6517 1034 0.6139
8 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate R BR 0.6075 0.5579 to 0.6571 352 0.6183
9 Dazzling Angel C W 0.6036 0.5785 to 0.6286 1443 0.5778
10 Spinner of Souls R G 0.6030 0.5775 to 0.6284 1403 0.6211
11 Felidar Savior C W 0.6013 0.5764 to 0.6262 1465 0.5736
12 Authority of the Consuls R W 0.6009 0.5724 to 0.6293 1120 0.5203
13 Kaito, Cunning Infiltrator M U 0.5955 0.5662 to 0.6248 1058 0.5827
14 Ruby, Daring Tracker U RG 0.5936 0.5415 to 0.6456 322 0.5699
15 Day of Judgment R W 0.5928 0.5634 to 0.6221 1058 0.5911
16 Sire of Seven Deaths M C 0.5918 0.5757 to 0.6079 3554 0.6203
17 Arahbo, the First Fang R W 0.5830 0.5581 to 0.6079 1486 0.6092
18 Sun-Blessed Healer U W 0.5813 0.5558 to 0.6067 1420 0.5848
19 Serra Angel U W 0.5800 0.5538 to 0.6061 1349 0.5477
20 Kykar, Zephyr Awakener R WU 0.5794 0.5296 to 0.6291 358 0.5744
21 Quilled Greatwurm M G 0.5753 0.5497 to 0.6010 1407 0.55
22 Cat Collector U W 0.5730 0.5475 to 0.5986 1418 0.5857
23 Scrawling Crawler R C 0.5728 0.5568 to 0.5888 3653 0.5755
24 Vampire Nighthawk U B 0.5722 0.5470 to 0.5974 1462 0.5823
25 Beast-Kin Ranger C G 0.5721 0.5469 to 0.5973 1464 0.5523
26 Angel of Finality U W 0.5697 0.5442 to 0.5951 1430 0.5668
27 Eager Trufflesnout U G 0.5687 0.5432 to 0.5942 1429 0.5647
28 Dreadwing Scavenger U UB 0.5654 0.5208 to 0.6100 454 0.6043
29 Make Your Move C W 0.5646 0.5351 to 0.5941 1064 0.5526
30 Armasaur Guide C W 0.5643 0.5384 to 0.5902 1387 0.5052

Bottom 15:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand 17Lands GIH WR
251 Banner of Kinship R C 0.4417 0.4228 to 0.4606 2629 0.5062
252 Sphinx's Tutelage M U 0.4415 0.4125 to 0.4705 1108 0.5039
253 Midnight Snack U B 0.4415 0.4124 to 0.4706 1099 0.4864
254 Goblin Bushwhacker M R 0.4393 0.4140 to 0.4645 1462 0.53
255 Brass's Bounty R R 0.4382 0.4071 to 0.4693 959 0.3714 (35 games)
256 Ravenous Amulet U C 0.4357 0.4172 to 0.4542 2739 0.5171
257 Exsanguinate U B 0.4342 0.4054 to 0.4630 1120 0.4818
258 Rite of the Dragoncaller M R 0.4252 0.3943 to 0.4561 963 0.5163
259 Bulk Up U R 0.4222 0.3913 to 0.4531 963 0.483
260 Swiftfoot Boots U C 0.4175 0.3988 to 0.4362 2646 0.4384
261 Wildwood Scourge U G 0.4159 0.3908 to 0.4409 1466 0.5121
262 Thousand-Year Storm R UR 0.4148 0.3560 to 0.4736 250 0.3479
263 Inspiring Call U G 0.4089 0.3799 to 0.4379 1083 0.4606
264 Rune-Sealed Wall U U 0.4054 0.3811 to 0.4296 1549 0.5177
265 Goblin Negotiation U R 0.3910 0.3614 to 0.4206 1026 0.5195

fdn-nonet-3k

Top 30 of 265:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand 17Lands GIH WR
1 Bloodthirsty Conqueror M B 0.6636 0.6093 to 0.7180 207 0.6272
2 Quilled Greatwurm M G 0.6460 0.5913 to 0.7008 201 0.55
3 Twinflame Tyrant M R 0.6203 0.5660 to 0.6746 208 0.6048
4 Sire of Seven Deaths M C 0.5866 0.5486 to 0.6245 576 0.6203
5 Mischievous Mystic U U 0.5820 0.5304 to 0.6336 252 0.5957
6 Felidar Savior C W 0.5800 0.5263 to 0.6336 218 0.5736
7 Angel of Finality U W 0.5800 0.5262 to 0.6337 214 0.5668
8 Perforating Artist U BR 0.5796 0.5134 to 0.6458 69 0.5748
9 Liliana, Dreadhorde General M B 0.5774 0.5195 to 0.6354 163 0.6412
10 Etali, Primal Storm R R 0.5766 0.5222 to 0.6310 206 0.5326
11 Authority of the Consuls R W 0.5764 0.5205 to 0.6323 186 0.5203
12 Sylvan Scavenging R G 0.5759 0.5193 to 0.6326 177 0.6183
13 Elenda, Saint of Dusk R WB 0.5718 0.5054 to 0.6383 44 0.6154
14 Giada, Font of Hope R W 0.5708 0.5168 to 0.6247 212 0.6043
15 Dragon Trainer U R 0.5689 0.5142 to 0.6235 201 0.5647
16 Spinner of Souls R G 0.5665 0.5142 to 0.6189 237 0.6211
17 Scrawling Crawler R C 0.5658 0.5271 to 0.6045 553 0.5755
18 Bigfin Bouncer C U 0.5647 0.5128 to 0.6166 245 0.5709
19 Kaito, Cunning Infiltrator M U 0.5631 0.5046 to 0.6216 156 0.5827
20 Vivien Reid M G 0.5600 0.5008 to 0.6192 148 0.6139
21 Dwynen, Gilt-Leaf Daen U G 0.5596 0.5065 to 0.6127 225 0.5293
22 Exemplar of Light R W 0.5590 0.5063 to 0.6116 232 0.5899
23 Felling Blow U G 0.5571 0.5001 to 0.6141 173 0.5871
24 Lathril, Blade of the Elves R BG 0.5566 0.4899 to 0.6233 56 0.4917
25 Dwynen's Elite C G 0.5562 0.5037 to 0.6087 235 0.5307
26 Niv-Mizzet, Visionary M UR 0.5554 0.4887 to 0.6221 50 0.468
27 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate R BR 0.5541 0.4875 to 0.6207 59 0.6183
28 Krenko, Mob Boss R R 0.5531 0.4987 to 0.6076 205 0.5533
29 Dazzling Angel C W 0.5531 0.5002 to 0.6060 227 0.5778
30 Banishing Light C W 0.5529 0.4964 to 0.6093 179 0.5745

Bottom 15:

Rank Card Rarity Colour Value 95% interval Games in hand 17Lands GIH WR
251 Grow from the Ashes C G 0.4279 0.3713 to 0.4846 177 0.4809
252 Doubling Season M G 0.4276 0.3677 to 0.4876 138 0.3945
253 Swiftfoot Boots U C 0.4211 0.3780 to 0.4643 409 0.4384
254 Wardens of the Cycle U BG 0.4205 0.3542 to 0.4868 42 0.5115
255 Grim Tutor M B 0.4203 0.3625 to 0.4782 163 0.484 (188 games)
256 Aegis Turtle C U 0.4149 0.3624 to 0.4673 237 0.4988
257 Aetherize U U 0.4119 0.3542 to 0.4696 165 0.5012
258 Inspiring Call U G 0.4075 0.3504 to 0.4647 170 0.4606
259 Brass's Bounty R R 0.4056 0.3460 to 0.4651 142 0.3714 (35 games)
260 Rune-Sealed Wall U U 0.4015 0.3501 to 0.4530 252 0.5177
261 Midnight Snack U B 0.4011 0.3433 to 0.4589 163 0.4864
262 Ravenous Amulet U C 0.3986 0.3559 to 0.4413 420 0.5171
263 Banner of Kinship R C 0.3876 0.3454 to 0.4297 433 0.5062
264 Divine Resilience U W 0.3839 0.3292 to 0.4386 202 0.5079
265 Goblin Surprise C R 0.3805 0.3216 to 0.4393 150 0.5257